Sample competency review comments

The next time you are completing a competency review, give some thought to the comments that you choose to leave.  Qualitative responses offer depth to the assessment, rather than just a number at the end of the day.  Remember that a competency assessment is a fantastic development exercise, it’s designed to identify strengths and areas for improvement.

Put yourself in the shoes of an employee.  Your manager has just completed a competency assessment of your Problem Solving skills.  From this assessment, it’s clear that there are some areas for improvement, namely around following up and seeking input from others.  Here’s a table of the manager’s ratings.

Problem SolvingNeverRarelySometimesUsuallyAlways
Analyses problems to prevent future occurrencesX
Follows up to ensure problems are solved satisfactorilyX
Develops alternative solutions where neededX
Seeks input from a variety of sources to determine the best solutionX
Resolves problems in a timely mannerX

Comment 1:

You rarely seek input from others.  This needs to be addressed.  Also your follow up is pretty poor.

Comment 2:

Problem solving is one of your strengths.  However, I think that you could improve the value of your solutions significantly by doing a couple of things:

  1. Developing a follow up process.  This will bring a more customer centric focus to your approach and help you to build relationships with others in the business.  At the moment, once the solution is out the door it tends to get forgotten about.
  2. Keeping an open mind about the best possible solution.  Often others will be able to provide you with some insight that will take your solution from good to great.

The second comment is by far the more valuable one.  Not only does it identify problem solving as a strength, but it also outlines two practical solutions to helping them improve.  These are an immediate and obvious catalyst for their development.

Recommended

How to give feedback like a pro

A critical component for every kind of manager is being able to give feedback. At the end of the day, all you want feedback to do is one of two things:

  • Reinforce good behaviour
  • Correct poor behaviour
Competencies are great

7 reasons competencies are great

Wondering if or why you should use competencies? We think so!

Read our handy guide to discover more.

Cognology's performance management system

Performance Management System

Our performance management system includes an objective library to make setting goals easier. The library includes pre-written goals that can be modified based on the roles in your organisation and the strategic plan.